Villanova Wildcats @ Seton Hall Pirates NCAAB 12/23/2025
If you love December college hoops with real stakes, this one has “Big East bite” written all over it. Villanova heads to Newark on Tuesday night, Dec. 23, 2025, to meet a Seton Hall team that’s humming under head coach Shaheen Holloway. The Pirates are sitting in the top tier of the conference table early with a 1-0 league mark and have yet to take the home floor in Big East play, while Villanova arrives with one of the most reliable identities in this league: poise, spacing, and late-game shotmaking.
Now to the betting angle. Over their last five, Seton Hall is averaging 76.6 points per game on offense while allowing just 63.0—a sturdy +13.6 margin in a sample that includes a conference road win. Villanova’s last-five profile shows balance, too: 76.0 points per game on offense and 67.0 allowed, a +9.0 margin. My model has this essentially in coin-flip territory with a slight lean to the more experienced late-game execution on the road. Market-wise, that implies a narrow moneyline shade toward Villanova in the range of a one-possession game, a total that could land in the mid-130s, and a spread in the small-dog/small-favorite window. Translation: we’re handicapping a grinder with punch-counterpunch rhythms.
Timing is everything in college hoops betting. Monitor NCAA Basketball odds for late injury news and lineup changes.
Our betting predictions: Villanova Wildcats @ Seton Hall Pirates
Best Bet: Totals – Under 137.5
1) Total: Under (best bet). Pick: Under (targeting the 137.5 at around -125 at BetMGM). Why: Both teams have recent defensive profiles that travel. Seton Hall is allowing just 63.0 per game across its last five, and Holloway’s groups thrive in a grind. Villanova’s defense is good enough to limit easy second chances and turn this into a possession-by-possession battle. The model projects this finishing a couple of possessions below a mid-130s total, with about a 56% hit rate (roughly -125 fair price at BetMGM). Betting tip: Under is my favorite angle on this board.
Don’t place your first bet without a boost. Learn how to claim the BetMGM bonus code and maximize your signup value.
Tip 2: Spread – Seton Hall +3 Points (home dog)
2) Pick: Seton Hall +3 or better (around -110 at BetMGM). Why: The Pirates’ defensive floor and their ability to generate tough rebounds have produced a +13.6 average margin over the last five, including impressive work away from home. At Newark, with Holloway’s game-planning and a top-four conference table position after an opening road win, Seton Hall has enough muscle to keep this within one possession—and live to steal it late. Betting tip: Take the points with the home side at +3 or better.
Tip 3: Moneyline – Villanova to Win
3) Pick: Villanova ML at best odds with DraftKings(model edge to about 52%). Why: The Wildcats’ late-game execution gives them a thesis for road wins in environments like Prudential Center. They’ve averaged 76.0 in the last five while keeping opponents to 67.0, and this program historically handles high-leverage half-court possessions with discipline. It’s tight, but the numbers lean Nova by a possession or less. Betting tip: Small plus-EV lean on the moneyline; not as strong as the total or spread angle.
Team Statistics
Seton Hall Pirates (current form: surging with a Big East road win on the board)
- Big East snapshot: 1-0 in league play, fourth in the table entering this matchup, and still to host their first home conference game.
- Last five form: 5-0, averaging 76.6 points per game on offense and allowing 63.0. That’s a +13.6 per-game margin that speaks to both ends of the floor.
- Last result context: A composed road win to start league action—textbook Holloway: physical, selective shot-making, and timely stops.
- Style keys: Tough on the glass, sound defensively, and comfortable in games that hinge on second-chance denial and set-piece execution. With head coach Shaheen Holloway pulling the strings, this team leans into identity more than pace, and that’s why totals often trend lower than raw talent would suggest.
Villanova Wildcats (current form: steady, battle-tested, and efficient)
- Big East snapshot: Opening their league slate here, but trending up after a quality non-con stretch that included an overtime road win—proof of late-game resilience.
- Last five form: 4-1, averaging 76.0 points per game on offense and 67.0 allowed for a +9.0 margin. The Wildcats’ offense is patient and perimeter-credible, and their defense late in games has closed doors.
- Style keys: Ball security, spacing, and calm under pressure. When the possession count dips, Villanova’s shot profile—inside-out patience and corner threes generated by ball reversals—gains value. That’s part of why my model grants them a small road edge despite Seton Hall’s form.
Keyplayer Statistics/Momentum/External Factors
Seton Hall’s edge starts with head coach Shaheen Holloway, whose defensive fingerprints are all over this roster: compact gaps, strong help, and collective rebounding. The Pirates’ recent surge suggests high confidence and connectedness. On the Villanova side, perimeter scoring depth and late-clock poise travel well, with wings who can create their own looks and finish possessions at the line. External factors to watch: potential availability notes—Villanova has managed around injury workloads this season up front, and Seton Hall’s rotation health has been monitored at times. Prudential Center gives the Pirates a legitimate bump, but Nova’s road temperament narrows that advantage. Expect a slower cadence, where the first team to string together consecutive stops dictates the outcome.
Last direct match
Villanova won the most recent head-to-head at home by a comfortable margin; Seton Hall will aim to flip the script in Newark.
Performance last 5 Matches
- Seton Hall Pirates: 5-0
- Villanova Wildcats: 4-1.
New to daily fantasy sports or looking to improve? Explore our DFS sports betting guide and learn how to build smarter lineups from the start.
TrustnBet Final Thoughts
Our card prioritizes the game flow. The best value lies on the Under because both teams’ recent defensive averages and coaching identities point toward a half-court, possession-scarce contest. Seton Hall + points is next: the Pirates’ last-five margin and Holloway’s home edge should translate into a one-possession game deep into the second half. Finally, our moneyline lean to Villanova reflects a small efficiency gap in late-game execution and shot profile—just enough to justify a modest play at about 52% win probability. In short: slow tempo, tight margins, and razor-thin separation. Under first, Seton Hall with the cushion, second, and Villanova’s narrow ML edge third.
