Chicago Fire vs New York RB Predictions & Odds - Major League Soccer Picks

Our soccer betting prediction for the match between Chicago Fire and New York RB on May 9, 2026, at Soldier Field, presents an intriguing clash. As both teams jostle for position in the Eastern Conference, this encounter is poised to be a significant encounter on Matchday 12 of the Major League Soccer season. Chicago Fire, under the guidance of Gregg Berhalter, are currently 5th in the conference and have demonstrated a strong home form with four wins in their last five home matches. Meanwhile, New York RB, managed by Michael Bradley, have struggled on the road, capturing only one victory in their away fixtures this season.

The Fire's 71% ball possession and an average of six shots on target per game indicate their offensive prowess, especially with Hugo Cuypers in blistering form. Conversely, New York RB have shown defensive vulnerabilities, having failed to keep a clean sheet in their last nine matches, which could be exploited by the Fire's attack. With these statistics in mind, our betting tips focus on Chicago Fire's strong home form and the likelihood of goals in this fixture.

Our 3 Betting Predictions for Chicago Fire vs New York RB

1. Home Win for Chicago Fire

Considering Chicago Fire's robust home form and New York RB's struggles on the road, the odds are in favor of a home win. Chicago has won four of their last five home matches, showcasing their ability to capitalize on home advantage. With New York RB failing to secure a win in their last five games, betting on a home win at -172 odds on BetMGM Sportsbook seems a strong choice.

2. Both Teams to Score

Despite New York RB's defensive woes, they have managed to score in matches, and Chicago Fire's offensive strategy often leaves them open at the back. This makes a case for both teams finding the net in this encounter. The odds of both teams scoring, available at -196, provide a promising return and align with the recent scoring trends of both teams.

3. Over 3.5 Goals

With attacking talents like Hugo Cuypers on the field and New York's leaky defense, an open game with plenty of chances is expected. The odds of over 3.5 goals at +100 offer an attractive proposition, considering both teams' recent scoring records and defensive frailties.

Further Predictions

Our tips

Total Goals

Over 4.5

There have been over 4.5 goals scored in 3 of Chicago Fire's last 4 matches.

There have been over 4.5 goals scored in 2 of New York RB's last 6 matches.

Top odds at bet365

Total Goals

Over 3.5

There have been over 3.5 goals scored in 3 of Chicago Fire's last 4 matches.

There have been over 3.5 goals scored in 4 of New York RB's last 6 matches.

Top odds at bet365

Double Chance

X2

Chicago Fire have drawn or lost 3 of their last 4 matches.

New York RB have won or drawn 2 of their last 6 matches.

Top odds at bet365

Team Statistics

Chicago Fire - Strong Home Form

Chicago Fire has been impressive at home, winning four out of their last five matches. Their recent 3-2 loss to FC Cincinnati was a hiccup, but they have shown resilience in bouncing back. Currently 5th in the Eastern Conference, they have amassed 17 points from 10 games, with a win percentage of 50%. Their offensive firepower, led by Hugo Cuypers, who has 10 goals in 7 matches, remains a key strength.

New York RB - Struggling for Consistency

New York RB finds themselves in 7th position, with 12 points from 11 matches. Their form has been inconsistent, with no wins in their last five outings, including a recent 2-0 home loss to FC Dallas. They have managed just one win away from home this season, and their defense has been a major concern, conceding 27 goals so far, leading to a win percentage of just 27%.

Latest Odds Boosts

🪂 DAILY DROP Profit Boost on ANY SPORT today 🔔: Profit boost percentage varies, total bet odds & max betting limits apply

Ends in

Expired

Eligibility: Must be 21+ and physically located in CA-ONT, AZ, CO, CT, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA (select parishes), MA, MD, ME, MI, MO, NC, NH, NJ, NY, OH, PA, TN, VA, VT, WA, WV, or WY. 18+ and physically located in DC/KY/NH/WY. 19+ and physically located in CA-ONT.

🚀 100% ACCA BOOST: Double your winnings on ANY SPORT! 🏆

Ends in

Expired

Key Player Statistics/Momentum/External Factors

Hugo Cuypers has been a standout performer for Chicago Fire, with 10 goals in 7 matches, making him the joint top scorer in the league. His ability to find the back of the net consistently makes him a pivotal figure in this encounter. For New York RB, Julian Hall has been the most effective forward with 6 goals in 11 matches, but the team's defensive frailties have overshadowed their attacking efforts. Injuries to key players like Justin Che could further impact their performance.

Last Direct Match

The last meeting between Chicago Fire and New York RB ended in a 1-0 victory for Chicago Fire, showcasing their ability to secure narrow wins at home.

Performance Last 5 Matches

Performance

Chicago Fire

Last games

Chicago Fire performance of the last 6 home matches

Victories

50%

Over 2.5

66%

New York RB

Last games

New York RB performance of the last 4 away matches

Victories

0%

Over 2.5

75%

TrustnBet Predictions Summary

Our betting tips focus on Chicago Fire's solid home record and the potential for goals given both teams' attacking capabilities. With a home win at -172, both teams to score at -196, and over 3.5 goals at +100 odds, we anticipate an exciting match at Soldier Field. These selections are based on current form, key player performances, and historical context favoring Chicago Fire in this matchup.