Everton FC vs Sunderland AFC Predictions & Odds - Premier League Picks

Get ready for an exciting clash in the Premier League as Everton FC hosts Sunderland AFC at the Hill Dickinson Stadium on Sunday, May 17, 2026. With Matchday 37 upon us, both teams are set to deliver an intriguing contest. Everton, currently in 10th place with 49 points, aims to secure a potential European spot. Sunderland, positioned 12th with 48 points, has already achieved their primary goal of Premier League survival in their first season back after an eight-year absence. In recent encounters, Everton has struggled to convert matches into wins, drawing four and losing three of their last seven games. Meanwhile, Sunderland has displayed a solid defense, evident from their recent 0-0 draw against Manchester United. As we dive into the soccer betting odds, the focus will be on Everton's capability to leverage their home advantage and Sunderland's ability to sustain their defensive resilience.

Our 3 Betting Predictions for Everton FC vs Sunderland AFC

1. Home Win for Everton FC

Our soccer betting pick for this match is a home win for Everton FC. Despite recent struggles, Everton is determined to make the most of their home advantage at Hill Dickinson Stadium. With a potential European spot on the line, David Moyes' side will be motivated to secure all three points. The betting market at BetMGM Sportsbook offers Everton win odds of -120, reflecting their status as favorites.

2. Both Teams Will Score

Considering both teams' recent performances, our soccer predictions suggest that both teams will find the back of the net. Everton's defense has shown vulnerabilities, conceding an average of 2.2 goals per game recently. Sunderland, on the other hand, has the potential to exploit these weaknesses. With odds of -125 at Bet365 for both teams to score, this market presents a viable betting opportunity.

3. Under 2.5 Goals

Our soccer betting prediction advises considering the Under 2.5 goals market. Both Everton and Sunderland have displayed trends of low-scoring games in recent outings, underlined by Sunderland's last two matches ending in ties with less than three goals. Betting odds at Bet365 provide -110 for Under 2.5 goals, indicating a tight contest is anticipated.

Further Predictions

Our tips

Total Goals

Over 3.5

There have been over 3.5 goals scored in 3 of Everton FC's last 5 matches.

There have been over 3.5 goals scored in 2 of Sunderland AFC's last 5 matches.

Top odds at bet365

Double Chance

X2

Everton FC have drawn or lost 5 of their last 5 matches.

Sunderland AFC have won or drawn 3 of their last 5 matches.

Top odds at bet365

Total Goals

Over 2.5

There have been over 2.5 goals scored in 5 of Everton FC's last 5 matches.

There have been over 2.5 goals scored in 2 of Sunderland AFC's last 5 matches.

Top odds at bet365

Team Statistics

Everton FC - Current Form Analysis

Everton FC is positioned 10th with a record of 13 wins, 10 ties, and 13 losses. Their recent form is characterized by a string of draws, with a 0% win rate in their last five matches. Everton's attacking potential has been evident with an average scoring rate, yet defensive issues remain with an average concession rate of 2.2 goals per game. The team’s home performance this season includes 6 wins, 5 ties, and 7 losses.

Sunderland AFC - Current Form Analysis

Sunderland AFC stands 12th in the league with an evenly balanced record of 12 wins, 12 ties, and 12 losses. Their recent form shows resilience, with a notable 0-0 tie against Manchester United. Sunderland's away performance has been less impressive, with 4 wins, 6 ties, and 8 losses, indicating potential challenges on the road. Despite these hurdles, Sunderland has managed to secure their Premier League status for another season.

Latest Odds Boosts

🪂 DAILY DROP Profit Boost on ANY SPORT today 🔔: Profit boost percentage varies, total bet odds & max betting limits apply

Ends in

Expired

Eligibility: Must be 21+ and physically located in CA-ONT, AZ, CO, CT, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA (select parishes), MA, MD, ME, MI, MO, NC, NH, NJ, NY, OH, PA, TN, VA, VT, WA, WV, or WY. 18+ and physically located in DC/KY/NH/WY. 19+ and physically located in CA-ONT.

🚀 100% ACCA BOOST: Double your winnings on ANY SPORT! 🏆

Ends in

Expired

Key Player Statistics/Momentum/External Factors

Key players for Everton include Beto, who leads their scoring charts with 11 goals, and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall. Sunderland's top performer is Brobbey with 6 goals in the Premier League. Everton's goalkeeper, Jordan Pickford, remains crucial in their defensive setup, while Sunderland’s Robin Roefs has been a standout with his recent penalty saves. External factors such as Everton’s injury concerns, including Idrissa Gueye and Jack Grealish, may influence the team's depth and overall performance. Sunderland's confidence is likely bolstered by their successful FA Cup penalty shootout against Everton.

Last Direct Match

The last encounter between Everton FC and Sunderland AFC ended in a 1-1 tie after regular time, with Sunderland prevailing 3-0 on penalties in the FA Cup.

Performance Last 5 Matches

Performance

Everton FC

Last games

Everton FC performance of the last 4 home matches

Victories

50%

Over 2.5

75%

Sunderland AFC

Last games

Sunderland AFC performance of the last 6 away matches

Victories

33%

Over 2.5

33%

TrustnBet Predictions Summary

Our three betting predictions for Everton vs. Sunderland focus on utilizing Everton's home field advantage, both teams' tendencies to score, and their recent trend towards low-scoring matches. The odds are favorable for a home win with Everton priced at -120 by BetMGM Sportsbook. Both teams are likely to find the net, supported by odds of -125. Lastly, considering the defensive focus of both teams, Under 2.5 goals at odds of -110 offers an attractive option for bettors.